The Jekyll and Hyde of Jim Nabors


Updated from a post originally published in 2013. 

JIm Nabors (1930-2017) is a difficult phenomenon to describe to people too young to have experienced him back in the day. He has two polar modes:

In one, he is the semi-retarded, good-hearted but naive hick Gomer Pyle, whom he played on The Andy Griffith Show and on his own Gomer Pyle U.S.M.C. (1964-1969), and then in endless forced exhumations as all tv stars are forced to do (Bob Denver, Don Adams, etc etc), in tv appearances and in films like The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas (1982), Stroker Ace (1983), and Cannonball Run II (1984).

Gomer Pyle was in syndication throughout the 70s, and let me tell you I watched it to death.  Like The Andy Griffith Show, which was set in a small Southern town in which there were no blacks and thus no civil rights movement, Gomer Pyle was set in a Marine barracks in the late 1960s in which there was mysteriously no Vietnam War. It essentially chronicled the conflicts between urban, smart, no-nonsense Sgt. Carter (Frank Sutton) and rural, accident-prone Pyle. Ronnie Schell played Pyle’s friend Duke. And as Pyle, Nabors provided the nation with the catchphrases “Well, GOLLEE!”, “Sherzayum!”, and “Surprise, surprise, surprise.”

Mode #2 for Nabors was that he was a singer — a very white, operatic, Broadway type singer, without an ounce of rock or swing or jazz in him. Sometimes he would stretch narrative credibility by doing it in the context of Gomer as in the clip below, but he also appeared on variety shows and also had several variety shows of his own over the years. Because he only sang the unhippest music, this other persona was considered (unintentionally) as funny as Gomer Pyle.

At any rate I think one could do a hilarious Jekyll and Hyde story using Jim Nabors’ two personae.

Nabors had yet a third persona, his character on the 1978 Sid and Marty Kroft Show The Lost Saucer, about which see my blogpost here. 

Closeted for many years, Nabors was married in 2013 to his longtime (38 year) companion Stan Cadwallader — they got hitched as soon as it was legal in Washington state. it was an inspirational story for many, for Nabors was 83 years old at the time.

One comment

  1. What about the true Mr Hyde persona you completely ignore. Jim Nabors was the paramour of Rock Hudson for years and Rock Hudson died of AIDS but Nabors escaped, or did he? Andy Griffiths had no blacks, Gomer Pyle had no Vietnam and Jim Nabors was the closet !


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.