I often like to joke that Room Service (1938) is the Marx Brothers film on which Zeppo made his greatest artistic mark. (The youngest brother had left the team four years before, but he engineered the deal to make this film at RKO as an agent).
I vacillate on which Marx Brothers film is their worst, but this one has been my candidate more than once (usually every time I watch it). Room Service is the one vehicle the Marx Brothers appeared in as a team that wasn’t crafted especially for their unique talents, and the one film in which they play characters semi-resembling real humans (except of course for the mysterious mute clown walking around with a lit candle on his head).
Room Service was originally a successful Broadway stage play by John Murray and Allen Boretz. The screenplay was tweaked by Morrie Ryskind to be more suitable for the team, but the task was clearly impossible. By itself it’s a mildly funny farce. An impecunious Broadway producer must scheme to keep his entire cast and crew in their hotel lodgings until opening night, so he can finally pay the bill. The play is a couple of hours of expedient lies, disguises and dodges. It’s kind of a mix between that extremely overdone plot about a Broadway producer dodging creditors until opening night with something rather like the stateroom scene in A Night at the Opera. Perhaps that was the attraction.
Groucho plays the producer, of course. And you know what? I NEVER want to see Groucho this vulnerable, with these quotidian problems. He makes a few weak wisecracks but they’re toothless. The Groucho we want in the movies OWNS the hotel, and anyone who irritates him winds up in a dumpster out back wearing a sign that says “kick me”. So the entire movie is painful from start to finish. Harpo fares much better. In a way the film belongs to him because the rest of it is so awful we watch him — almost desperately — for relief, and he does offer some. Most people like the “eating scene” best (where the hungry Harpo relentlessly eats everything in sight like a locust). It is reminiscent of a similar scene in A Night at the Opera, but you know what? It’s all we got. Chico has very little indeed to do. One of the minor roles in the play was just altered to have an Italian accent — a far cry from “sanity clause”. The faux Zeppo role is played by the Grady Sutton-esque Frank Albertson as a rube playwright from upstate Oswego. A very young Lucille Ball is a funny secretary and an even younger (teenaged!) Ann Miller is the love interest (that will get you arrested nowadays). Most annoying of all (to me) is the foil, a hotel manager played by Donald MacBride, who runs around with his eyes popping out yelling “Jumping Butterballs!” The last thing our compromised Marx Brothers need in this picture is competition for laughs. And how very lame that this is what is supposed to achieve them.
After the success of A Day at the Races, this has to have been a major come down, actually losing money at the box office. How pathetic that fact is will be most apparent when you consider how little was evidently spent on the film, in terms of production values. It all takes place almost entirely in one room. Ironically it is more stagebound than any of their previous movies including The Cocoanuts and Animal Crackers, both of which had an actual excuse. It is still a play. It doesn’t feel like a movie. But this is 1938. Surely we should be seeing this “cast of 19” everybody keeps talking about, and the rehearsals they are supposed to be having. Even in Love Happy we get to see the beleaguered cast’s rehearsals!
My theory is that this film lowered the bar considerably for what was expected of the Marx Brothers, and for what resources would be extended to them going forward. Film producers saw this film and said, ” Oh! they’ll do this! I guess we dont have to go the whole nine yards with them anymore.” And they didn’t.
For more on comedy film history please check out my new book: Chain of Fools: Silent Comedy and Its Legacies from Nickelodeons to Youtube, just released by Bear Manor Media, also available from amazon.com etc etc etcTo find out about the history of vaudeville, consult No Applause, Just Throw Money: The Book That Made Vaudeville Famous, available at Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and wherever nutty books are sold.
Well, he couldn’t use the stage version’s catchphrase: “God damn it!!!”
I saw a newspaper clipping stating that the Marx Brothers were going to abandon their characters totally for “Room Service” and just play it straight, specifically due to the new flavor of the month in comedy: The Ritz Brothers. At the time, it was like Abbott & Costello emerging and pulling ahead of Laurel and Hardy, or Martin and Lewis pulling ahead of Abbott & Costello.
Thank god the Ritz Brothers crashed and burned in about three years. Can’t stand them. But they were a genuine threat in popularity at the time.
I’m inclined to pick the claustrophobic ROOM SERVICE, which seems a particularly awful choice for the Marx Brothers, as their worst film, although I find the MGM musical numbers that don’t involve “deadpan diva” Virginia O’ Brien cringe-worthy. Wonder how it would play if Lucy’s role was expanded, Groucho and Chico were replaced by Bobby Clark (with real glasses) and Jack Carson, the actual Grady Sutton substituted for “faux Zeppo” and the parts for Harpo, Ann Miller and the “JUMPING BUTTERBALLS” hotel manager eliminated.
That sounds like a recipe for genius! I agree with you re: RS. Many’s the time I did put it last, it’s a tough slog alright, but I give it a couple of points for being a relatively good script at least…
I can’t help thinking that what really happened to the Marx Brothers film career was that they ran afoul of changing trends. It’s tempting to think they’d have made more DUCK SOUPs if they’d stayed at Paramount, but “Anarchic” comedy in features died out after 1934-No more MEET THE BARONs or DIPLOMANIACS. Audiences probably wanted more story. And after IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT(Or so I’ve read) “Romantic comedy” took over from comedies starring comedians, who got demoted to “B” or minor films. MGM might have been particularly unsympathetic to comedians, but were any studios hiring the best writers who were out there for a comedy team in 1939? Bigger budget films for comics made a kind of comeback in the 40s, but mostly for radio stars.
There really was no haven at the time
I’m enjoying this series. I do have to say, I enjoyed Room Service, but it’s been some time since I’ve seen it. Perhaps I wouldn’t like it as much now. But I do remember enjoying it when I watched it. I wouldn’t say I would put it anywhere near their worst.
Hail and Farewell!!
Although much maligned, this one does give me a few chuckles:
*Harpo chasing the turkey with a baseball bat
*Harpo using the squeaky kewpie doll to say “Ahhh!”
*The ferocious eating scene depicted above
*Chico and Harpo putting on (and taking off) several suits of clothes (“Now I know how Gypsy Rose Lee feels”)
agreed! I like those moments too